Conservative Guard
  • Home
  • Breaking News
  • US
  • World News
  • China
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Finance
  • Entertainment
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Breaking News
  • US
  • World News
  • China
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Finance
  • Entertainment
No Result
View All Result
theTotalStory | Conservative News & Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Home Finance

Supreme Court Hears Jack Daniel’s Dog Toy Lawsuit

Conservative Guard by Conservative Guard
March 22, 2023
in Finance
0
Supreme Court Hears Jack Daniel’S Dog Toy Lawsuit
7
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The U.S. Supreme Court Wednesday is set to hear a trademark clash between Jack Daniel’s and a dog accessory company behind a parody chew toy resembling the distiller’s widely recognized black-label whiskey bottle.

The dispute pits the whiskey brand’s trademark rights against legal protections for creative expression – in this case a send-up by Phoenix-based VIP Products LLC of Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7 Tennessee whiskey bottle featuring dog poop-themed changes like a label reading “the Old No. 2, on your Tennessee Carpet.”

Jack Daniel’s Properties Inc, owned by Louisville, Kentucky-based Brown-Forman Corp, is appealing a lower court’s ruling that the pun-laden “Bad Spaniels” vinyl chew toy qualifies as an “expressive work” protected by the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment.

At issue is whether VIP Products should be shielded from liability for alleged harms its chew toy poses to Jack Daniel’s by potentially misleading customers into associating the product with the whiskey maker or tarnishing the company’s famous trademark.

Industry groups backing the Lynchburg, Tennessee-based whiskey brand, established in 1866, have said the dispute holds enormous stakes for corporate America’s ability to safeguard its brands and reputations.

“This case is no laughing matter,” said Courtney Armour, chief legal officer at the industry group Distilled Spirits Council. “While the case involves dog toys, even allegedly ‘humorous’ knock-offs can confuse consumers as to what messaging and products well-known alcohol beverage brands endorse.”

A 2,300-strong group of authors took the opposite view, saying a win for Jack Daniel’s could lead to a “catastrophic chilling effect” over worries that creative expression might spark litigation.

“If the threat of legal sanction hangs over the heads of writers, their literary characters may no longer use iPhones, eat at McDonald’s or visit Disneyland,” the group wrote in a brief to the justices.

The San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2020 ruled in favor of VIP Products on two separate grounds. The 9th Circuit said the Bad Spaniels toy was an “expressive work” and thus potentially shielded under the First Amendment from Jack Daniel’s trademark infringement claim.

On this point, the 9th Circuit returned the case for further proceedings to a federal judge in Arizona with instructions to apply a legal test stemming from a landmark 1989 trademark dispute between actress Ginger Rogers and film director Federico Fellini. The judge ruled for VIP Products after applying the so-called “Rogers test,” which lets artists lawfully use another’s trademark when doing so has artistic relevance to their work and would not explicitly mislead consumers about its source.

The 9th Circuit also ruled that VIP Product’s use of the Jack Daniel’s trademark was noncommercial because it was used not only to sell dog toys but also “to convey a humorous message,” and thus had not tarnished the distiller’s distinctive mark.

President Joe Biden’s administration supports Jack Daniel’s appeal.

A ruling is expected by the end of June.


© 2023 Thomson/Reuters. All rights reserved.

Related

Previous Post

Economists See Fed Balance Sheet in New Light

Next Post

More Banks Will Fail Over Next 2 Years: Man CEO

Next Post
More Banks Will Fail Over Next 2 Years: Man Ceo

More Banks Will Fail Over Next 2 Years: Man CEO

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay Connected test

  • 11.3k Subscribers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Former Arizona State Student Appeals Conviction For Distributing Constitution Copies

Former Arizona State Student Appeals Conviction for Distributing Constitution Copies

January 27, 2023
Why Adani’s $100 Billion Loss Hasn’t Tanked India’s Markets

Why Adani’s $100 Billion Loss Hasn’t Tanked India’s Markets

February 11, 2023
Ukraine Attacks Russia’S Hold On Southern City Of Kherson

Ukraine attacks Russia’s hold on southern city of Kherson

October 27, 2022
Women Balk At Chinese Government Plans To Raise Birth Rate

Uyghurs Challenge the World’s Selective Memories of Genocide on Holocaust Remembrance Day

January 27, 2023
Tensions Rise On Peninsula Over Fears North Korean Eyeing ‘Tactical’ Nukes With New Policy

Tensions rise on peninsula over fears North Korean eyeing ‘tactical’ nukes with new policy

0
Times Square May Get One Of The Few Spectacles It Lacks: A Casino

Times Square May Get One of the Few Spectacles It Lacks: A Casino

0
Border Containers 34754 C0 435 5219

Arizona refuses U.S. demand to remove shipping containers from border

0
How Finnair’s Huge Bet On Faster Flights To Asia Suddenly Came Undone

How Finnair’s Huge Bet on Faster Flights to Asia Suddenly Came Undone

0
‘Succession’ Finale: 5 Questions To Consider As You Get Ready For The End Game

‘Succession’ finale: 5 questions to consider as you get ready for the end game

May 27, 2023
Roger Waters Concert Outfit Spurs Berlin Police Probe For Possible Incitement

Roger Waters concert outfit spurs Berlin police probe for possible incitement

May 27, 2023
New Bill To Build Athletics Stadium On Las Vegas Strip Caps Nevada’S Cost At $380 Million

New bill to build Athletics stadium on Las Vegas Strip caps Nevada’s cost at $380 million

May 27, 2023
Celine Dion Cancels European Concerts ‘Until I’M Really Ready To Be Back On Stage’

Celine Dion cancels European concerts ‘until I’m really ready to be back on stage’

May 26, 2023

Recent News

‘Succession’ Finale: 5 Questions To Consider As You Get Ready For The End Game

‘Succession’ finale: 5 questions to consider as you get ready for the end game

May 27, 2023
Roger Waters Concert Outfit Spurs Berlin Police Probe For Possible Incitement

Roger Waters concert outfit spurs Berlin police probe for possible incitement

May 27, 2023
New Bill To Build Athletics Stadium On Las Vegas Strip Caps Nevada’S Cost At $380 Million

New bill to build Athletics stadium on Las Vegas Strip caps Nevada’s cost at $380 million

May 27, 2023
Celine Dion Cancels European Concerts ‘Until I’M Really Ready To Be Back On Stage’

Celine Dion cancels European concerts ‘until I’m really ready to be back on stage’

May 26, 2023

TrendingNews

Recipe: Creamy Springtime Asparagus Pasta Defined By Textural Contrast

RECIPE: Creamy springtime asparagus pasta defined by textural contrast

by Conservative Guard
May 22, 2023
0

For Two Actors, Genuine Miracle Was ‘The Chosen’ Becoming A Streaming Success

For two actors, genuine miracle was ‘The Chosen’ becoming a streaming success

by Conservative Guard
May 24, 2023
0

New updates

‘Succession’ Finale: 5 Questions To Consider As You Get Ready For The End Game

‘Succession’ finale: 5 questions to consider as you get ready for the end game

by Conservative Guard
May 27, 2023
0

Roger Waters Concert Outfit Spurs Berlin Police Probe For Possible Incitement

Roger Waters concert outfit spurs Berlin police probe for possible incitement

by Conservative Guard
May 27, 2023
0

Browse by Category

  • Breaking News
  • Business
  • China
  • Crime
  • Entertainment
  • Finance
  • Politics
  • US
  • World News

© 2022 www.conservativeguard.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Conservative Guard

© 2022 www.conservativeguard.com

Go to mobile version